This blog is intended to explain the difference between mechanically actuated diaphragm metering pumps and hydraulically actuated metering pumps; after the ground work has been laid, we will discuss the advantages of Madden type DDB double diaphragm construction and actuation, in comparison to a hydraulic metering pump’s construction and actuation.
Mechanically actuated metering pumps, are driven by a motor, worm gears, drive shaft, eccentric and piston. The motor speed is first slowed or reduced down to a desired stroking speed using worm gears. These worm gears are what will then turn the drive shaft at a desired speed and the drive shaft will turn an eccentric which is a type of cam; this ultimately provides the stroking motion of the piston. Madden pumps, as an example, have a molded rubber diaphragm with a screw on the back side of it that is directly fastened to the piston. The forward and reward stroke of the piston directly actuates the primary diaphragm. When the piston is pulled rearward it pulls the diaphragm rearward and that creates a vacuum that sucks liquid into the pump. As the piston and diaphragm move forward liquid is pushed out of the pump.
(Term: primary diaphragm- the diaphragm that comes into direct contact with the liquid being pumped).
Hydraulically actuated diaphragm metering pumps, have the same starting components, meaning they also use a motor, worm gears, and a drive shaft/eccentric/piston of some sort to accomplish the reciprocating motion. However, the piston (usually a plunger) does not come in direct contact with the primary diaphragm. Between the piston and the diaphragm is hydraulic fluid. The reciprocating motion of the piston pressurizes the hydraulic oil which pushes on the diaphragm.
So this was a brief explanation of the differences. Both mechanically actuated and hydraulically actuated metering pumps are well suited to pump dangerous and corrosive chemicals. However, hydraulic pumps have the potential to incur expensive consequences when a leak occurs. This is due to the barrier fluid used to actuate a hydraulic pump’s primary diaphragm. If the barrier fluid enters the process, it could have dire affects on a product. Let’s take a look at where a Madden mechanically actuated metering pump can have an advantage over hydraulically actuated metering pumps.
Madden type DDB double diaphragm metering pump vs Hydraulic double diaphragm metering pump
When pumping dangerous or corrosive chemicals, metering pump manufacturers will suggest adding a secondary/backup diaphragm. Madden does this with their type DDB double diaphragm construction, which is comparable to a double diaphragm hydraulically actuated metering pump.
The main difference?
With the type DDB double diaphragm “hardware” is used to connect the piston to the primary diaphragm, rather than a barrier oil. As you can imagine, when hydraulic pumps add another diaphragm, they add another cavity, or barrier, and fill this with another oil (a.k.a. barrier fluid) to actuate it. Likewise, when mechanically actuated pumps add a secondary diaphragm, they need a secondary piston to be placed between the two diaphragms.
Example of MF series type DDB double diaphragm construction
So what is the advantage of a mechanically actuated pump over a hydraulically actuated pump? We believe the pivotal advantage stems from the fact that diaphragm fatigue/rupture is unavoidable; and on a hydraulically actuated pump it could cause thousands of dollars in damages or wasted products when hydraulic oil or a barrier fluid is pumped into the application.
Mechanically actuated advantage: these pumps cannot ruin a product due to barrier fluid contaminating the process. The Madden type DDB double diaphragm construction, as an example, contains no fluids in the spacer between the double diaphragm construction, only a secondary piston. This means no fluids can be pumped into the product.
Hydraulically actuated liability: ruptures in the primary diaphragm could cause the hydraulic pump to pump barrier fluid into the product, thus ruining an entire batch of product.
Point being, diaphragms will inevitably fatigue and rupture. There are precautions you take to avoid unnecessary damages (which we’ll talk about later in this blog) including leak detectors and regular maintenance, but nothing can beat the assurance of a dry chamber when it comes to pumping sensitive liquids like pharmaceuticals and food grade liquids.
Here’s a quick story to help understand how this peace of mind could have been achieved…
Example: we recently were brought an inquiry for a large pharmaceutical company who had a costly malfunction. One of their many hydraulically actuated diaphragm metering pumps had a diaphragm reach fatigue; the problem for them was the double disc system used a barrier fluid acting as the hydraulic actuator for the primary diaphragm.
When the primary diaphragm failed, the barrier fluid entered the pharmaceutical product being pumped and ruined the entire batch.
Mechanically actuated diaphragm pumps do not have any fluid between the secondary diaphragm and the primary diaphragm. In this case, it was suggested they take a look at the Madden diaphragm metering pump line. Had this large pharmaceutical company been using a Madden pump with a type DDB double diaphragm construction, their worst case scenario would have been a minor loss in volume of product, not an entire batch being contaminated.
Think of a mechanically actuated metering pump’s construction as the final precaution that will answer every “what if” and “you never know”.
Well, with Madden mechanically actuated metering pump and a type DDB double diaphragm, you know your answer is only a minor loss in product by volume equivalent to the time the pumps ran with a ruptured diaphragm. And one last advantage, repairing the hydraulic pumps can be messy and complicated, Madden wetted end repairs can be done in 10 minutes with an adjustable wrench.
Added Safety Feature Available with the Madden type DDB double diaphragm construction: Leak Detecting Pressure Switch
As discussed earlier, Madden metering pumps equipped with a DDB double diaphragm have a secondary back up diaphragm, a spacer, secondary piston, and primary diaphragm. The secondary diaphragm is there to make sure the liquid being pumped never comes into contact with interior components of the pump, which means only minor wetted end repairs will ever be necessary.
The other feature that this section in the blog is referring to, is the weep hole in the spacer. The weep hole allows for a visual aid showing when the pump’s primary diaphragm has a leak. It has a 1/4” NPT connection where a leak detecting pressure switch can be installed. The pressure inside the spacer (between the secondary and primary diaphragms) will be the same as the ambient air surrounding the pump. So with the leak detecting pressure switch set to its lowest setting, if any pressure at all builds inside the spacer, it will be due to a leak, and the leak detecting pressure switch will then immediately activate. You can wire the leak detecting pressure switch to either sound an alarm or directly turn off the pump.
A Madden diaphragm metering pump with a type DDB double diaphragm and leak detecting pressure switch will be plenty to give you peace of mind that your application will never leak or spray dangerous chemicals around the shop floor or surroundings; and if that isn’t enough, remember you can always fall back on the mechanics of a mechanically actuated pump, it will never waste a batch.
If you’re pumping a dangerous liquid, or a liquid that must not be contaminated in anyway, consider a Madden mechanically actuated diaphragm metering pump. They are extremely accurate, consistent, and durable. Our metering pumps are made of aluminum bodies and heavy duty construction for the interior components and everything is made and assembled in the U.S.A.